Same, but Different

Intelius.com has informed me with a red check next to each of the following categories that they have information on
Robert A. Caigan.
They are supposedly in possession of his...

Phone #
Address
Avg. Income
Relatives

I need to pay them for a subscription
in order to be given his phone number.
I am almost smiling writing this,
which is much better than the rage I felt ten minutes ago.
Imagine if it were true?
What would I pay for that phone number?

I wonder if this constitutes legal fraud?

Respectfully,
Bob's Daughter